Top Italian Scientists plead for animal testing

Read time: 3 mins

Gruppo 2003 - the Italian Association of the Top 50 Italian Scientists - few days ago launched an appeal from its website ( opposing the Italian Parliament’s attempt at distorting the European Directive on animal experimentation, which risks cutting Italy out from vital fields of biomedical research if the just approved bans will not be immediately amended.

“The umpteenth humiliation for scientific research in Italy.” Silvio Garattini, director of Mario Negri Institute in Milan, does not hide indignation and extreme concern in his open letter to the Italian Ministry of Research, University and Education, Maria Chiara Carrozza. “This law is completely irrational” continues the scientist “research on human tumours implanted in mice and abuse-substances administering to animals will be now banned. Why? It does not make any sense, it’s ridiculous and will raise indignation abroad, adding up to the list of senseless laws like therapy Di Bella, trial against geophysicists, Stamina and so on.”

So, what happened? The Italian law was supposed to acknowledge the essence and meaning of the European Directive 2010/63/EU which does not forbid animals testing, but regulates their use and breeding for scientific purposes. Few days ago, however, the voted art.12 introduced several new bans, affecting both fundamental and translational research (which looks for diseases’ cures) and also animals breeding for experimentation, de facto overturning the inspiring principles and the indications of the Directive.

The art.12 itself shows contradictions, generally allowing animal experimentation for treatment-oriented research, but then banning their use for xenotransplantation, which is fundamental for developing innovative and experimental therapies for severe pathologies - cancer included - besides researching safest and more advanced types of cardiac valves. Even though these techniques already saved millions of human lives, according to the art.12 Italy should be the only Nation in the whole world banning this research field.
Equally unclear are the reasons behind the prohibition of animal testing for abuse substances, since understanding addition-mechanisms is essential for developing adequate therapies.

The new law, furthermore, forbids the breeding of cats, dogs and not-human primates for scientific experimentation, once again contradicting the European Directive - which invites the Member States to define rules for the animals breeding but does not ban it – and heavily affecting the costs and quality of Italian biomedical research, which will be depending upon foreign breeding stations or will be forced to move abroad.

“If applied, art.12 will cause the blockage of grants, both future and already allocated, for fundamental research” assert the top Italian Scientists, denouncing also the total absence of consultation with the scientific community: “It would be like taking decisions heavily affecting the productivity and competitiveness of metalworker industries without consulting either the metalworkers or the industries, but, on the contrary, applying an urgent procedure which does not allow any intervention”.

Gruppo 2003’s appeal for the amendment of art.12 has been already signed by more than 2,120 researchers. Join in and sign here for a law on animal testing that brings Italy back in Europe.

altri articoli

Research agency: our proposals to the government and parliament

Gruppo 2003: It is important that the Research Agency is transparent and independent from politics, starting from the choice of its governing bodies.

The Italian Government has finally proposed a National Agency for Research, which has been advocated for many years by the Gruppo 2003, a charity of Italian highly Cited scientists focused on Italian research policy. For the moment, information on the characteristics of the Agency is contained in Article 28 of the Draft Budget Law for 2020, which will be discussed in the Chambers in the coming days.